Welcome to Plumer Insurance Agency

Plumer Insurance Agency has proudly served Seville, Ohio and the surrounding communities since 1972. Now in our fifth decade, we’ve built lasting relationships with generations of individuals, families, and businesses across northern Ohio by focusing on what matters most: clear guidance, reliable coverage, and personal service you can count on.

Today, we serve approximately 3,500 clients and work with many of the nation’s leading insurance carriers. This allows us to compare coverage options efficiently and match each client with policies that fit their needs and budget, without guesswork or pressure.

Jim, Emma, and Jane bring more than 75 combined years of professional insurance experience to Plumer Insurance Agency. Our approach is straightforward and conscientious, taking the time to understand your situation so we can recommend coverage that truly protects you.

Our goals are simple:

Reduce unnecessary insurance costs
Identify and eliminate gaps in coverage

Whether you’re reviewing an existing policy or exploring new coverage, our team is here to help guide you toward the best possible solution. We invite you to request a no-cost, no-obligation insurance review and see the difference a local, independent agency can make.

James Harris
Owner, Plumer Insurance Agency

Click on photos to learn more about us

Jim Harris

Agency Owner

Emma Bair

Insurance Agent

Jane Rych

Insurance Agent

Why Choose Plumer As Your Independent Insurance Agency?

Personalized, Comprehensive Services

At Plumer Insurance Agency, our experienced team takes the time to understand your situation before recommending coverage. We work with a broad network of top-rated insurance carriers, allowing us to research and compare policies on your behalf. The result is coverage options tailored to your needs and budget, without the time and frustration of shopping quotes on your own.
Unbiased Guidance You Can Trust

As an independent agency, our responsibility is to you, not to any single insurance company. This independence allows us to provide honest, objective advice focused on what best protects you, your family, or your business. We help you make informed decisions with confidence, knowing your coverage aligns with your goals.
Flexible Coverage for Every Stage of Life

We offer a full range of insurance solutions, including auto, home, life, condo, personal umbrella, classic car, motorcycle, and business insurance. With access to multiple carriers, we can adapt your coverage as your needs change, whether you’re protecting a growing family, valuable assets, or a business you’ve worked hard to build.
Ongoing Support and Claims Advocacy

Our service doesn’t stop once your policy is in place. We remain your advocate, providing ongoing support for policy updates, questions, and claims. When issues arise, we work directly with your insurance carrier to help ensure a smooth process and fair outcomes.
Contact Us Today

Choosing the right insurance agency matters. At Plumer Insurance Agency, we make it easy by combining local service with experienced guidance and strong carrier relationships. Contact us today to explore coverage options designed to protect what matters most and give you lasting peace of mind.